I have been thinking a great deal lately about some striking statistics discussing the state of the American Jewish community since The Surge began on October 7, 2023. As we have said before, The Surge is a measurably significant rise in engagement across the Jewish community spanning almost every demographic and category, according to a study conducted by Jewish Federations of North America.

Still today, nearly two years later, it is believed that 31% of the community is still actively surging. This is especially true for young adults who are seeking local Jewish friends and activities, especially those that are non-political; and mid-lifers (like me) who are seeking meaning, solidarity, and spiritual connections appropriate to our phase in life. And of course there are so many others who have been actively engaged before The Surge – some even for decades.

As you can imagine, the goal of the Jewish Federation is to act swiftly to welcome those who want to engage into our midst. To that end, in addition to our regular programs and services, we are creating new opportunities like Koach, Women’s Engagement, and Ignite to open new pathways to get involved.

As this trend study gets deeper into the weeds, it looks at our community’s attitudes towards Israel. We at the Federation strongly and unapologetically support the State of Israel and pray every day for the release of our hostages. We are also proud to learn that those who are involved in The Surge are in line with our position, having increased emotional attachment to Jews in Israel by 71%.

This attachment, however positive, is also markedly complex and teaches us that how we talk about Israel can both bring us together and tear us apart. Nearly half (49%) of Jews feel like the American Jewish community does not allow for nuanced conversations about the war. Jews are also divided into thirds on the challenge of how the Jewish community is handling the topic of Israel. One third (34%) feel like our community is not strong and outspoken enough in support of Israel and about another third (39%) feel like the community is too hardline in support.

That there is a lack of consensus inside our community is certainly nothing new or surprising. Afterall, as the story goes, “two Jews, three synagogues.”

The important thing to remember is that we are still one people with a shared history and the dream of a united future where our children’s children’s children can stand up proudly and safely declare themselves a Jew.

As we approach the High Holidays, let us come together in prayer and solidarity, striving for lasting peace. We wish you all a Happy and Sweet New Year.

Disclaimer:This article was written in July 2025 as we approach Day 650 of the war in Israel.